Request Free Consultation
To get answers to questions about your injury, contact Catalano Law for a FREE case evaluation. We’ll assess your case, explain your legal options, and recommend the next steps at no cost. We’re here when you need us.
Contact Form
General Contact Form
After a serious accident, the bills don’t wait. Medical costs, lost wages, and the emotional toll pile up quickly. The insurance company may offer you a settlement, but will it cover what you’ve lost?
Without legal guidance, you could leave thousands (or even tens of thousands) of dollars on the table. That’s where our experienced Syracuse personal injury lawyers can help. With our knowledge, negotiation skills, and resources, our attorneys consistently secure better outcomes than people who go it alone.
According to a survey by Nolo.com, on average, injury victims with an attorney secured about $77,600 in compensation, while those who went without legal help recovered only around $17,600.
The Personal Injury Settlement Negotiation Process
Settlement negotiations typically unfold in a series of steps, each designed to build a strong foundation for your claim:
- Initial Case Evaluation and Damage Calculation
Where does your case begin? A lawyer investigates how the crash happened, who may be liable, and how badly you were hurt. From there, they translate those details into numbers: medical bills, lost income, pain and suffering, and even future costs like diminished earning capacity. - Gathering and Organizing Evidence
Without evidence, your claim collapses. That’s why attorneys gather everything: medical records, police reports, photographs, witness statements, and even expert testimony. Every piece adds weight, making it harder for an insurance adjuster to downplay your losses. - Preparing a Demand Package
Think of the demand letter as your opening move. It lays out how the accident happened, the harm you’ve suffered, and the full compensation you’re owed. A strong demand letter signals to the insurance company that your case is serious and so are you. - Presenting the Initial Demand
Once the demand letter is ready, your attorney sends it to the insurance company. The insurer typically responds with a counteroffer far lower than your claim’s value, which begins the negotiation phase. - Engaging in Back-and-Forth Negotiations
Ever feel pressured to accept less just to end the stress? That’s the insurer’s playbook. Your lawyer shields you from that pressure, using local verdicts and settlement data to push back and keep the talks firmly in your favor.
- Knowing When to Settle vs. Litigate
What if the insurer won’t budge? That’s when your lawyer helps you decide to either accept the current offer or take the fight to court. Either way, you know the risks, rewards, and next steps. Of course, no decision about settlement versus litigation makes sense until you understand the full scope of your damages.
How Settlement Values Are Calculated
One of the most common mistakes in personal injury cases is underestimating the value of a claim. Lawyers can make sure every dollar is accounted for:
- Economic Damages: Medical bills, lost income, rehabilitation costs, and any out-of-pocket expenses
- Non-Economic Damages: Pain and suffering, emotional distress, and diminished quality of life
- Future Damages: Anticipated surgeries, long-term care needs, and the impact on your ability to work in the future
In New York, comparative negligence laws also matter. If you’re found partly at fault, your settlement can be reduced by that percentage. Insurers tend to inflate the victim’s blame, but skilled attorneys know how to push back and limit unfair reductions.
Common Insurance Company Tactics to Minimize Payouts
Insurance companies are businesses, and their goal is to protect profits. They often use strategies designed to minimize payouts, including:
- Offering quick, low settlements before the full extent of injuries is known
- Suggesting you were more at fault than you really were
- Questioning the necessity of certain treatments
- Dragging out negotiations in hopes you’ll accept less out of financial stress
Experienced Syracuse personal injury lawyers recognize these tactics and know how to respond.
The Value a Lawyer Brings to Your Settlement
Hiring an attorney is about advocacy and strategy. Lawyers bring:
- Legal knowledge of New York law, including comparative negligence rules, that affect settlement values
- Experience with insurance adjusters and the lowball tactics they use
- Access to experts like doctors and accident reconstructionists who can strengthen your claim
- Understanding of local courts and juries, which insurers factor into their risk calculations
- Negotiation skills that make sure your story is told with authority and backed by law
Why Work With Catalano Law?
At Catalano Law, we’ve spent years standing up for accident victims in Syracuse. We understand the local courts, we’ve seen every insurance tactic in the book, and we know how to calculate the full scope of your losses. Most importantly, we fight for the best possible outcome so you can focus on recovery instead of worrying about bills.
Get the Settlement You Deserve, Call Catalano Law Today
When insurers stall, lowball, or pressure you to settle, we stand firm. Our Syracuse personal injury lawyers know how to win the fight for fair compensation. Call Catalano Law today for a free case evaluation and take control of your claim.
