Request Free Consultation
To get answers to questions about your injury, contact Catalano Law for a FREE case evaluation. We’ll assess your case, explain your legal options, and recommend the next steps at no cost. We’re here when you need us.
Contact Form
General Contact Form
Accidents don’t just cause broken bones, medical bills, or vehicle damage; they can also lead to long-term consequences. At Catalano Law, we’ve seen how post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is one of the most common and most misunderstood effects of serious collisions. For many survivors, the fear, panic, and emotional disruption that follow an accident become just as disabling as physical harm.
In New York, emotional and psychological injuries like PTSD are recognized under the law, and victims can pursue compensation for them. But because these injuries aren’t visible, they’re often harder to document, harder to prove, and require stronger evidence than physical injuries.
Knowing how New York handles PTSD claims and working with an experienced Syracuse car accident lawyer can make all the difference in getting the support, validation, and compensation you need to move forward.
Common Symptoms of Post-Traumatic Stress After Accidents
PTSD does not manifest in the same way for everyone. Some symptoms appear immediately, while others gradually build over days or weeks. After an accident, victims may experience:
- Intrusive Memories and Flashbacks: Survivors may find themselves reliving the crash again and again, sometimes through sudden, overwhelming flashbacks and other times through intrusive memories that disrupt daily life.
- Severe Anxiety About Driving or Being a Passenger: Some victims avoid driving, experience panic behind the wheel, or feel a surge of dread when they approach the scene of the crash.
- Nightmares and Sleep Disturbances: Recurring nightmares, racing thoughts, and fear of reliving the crash often lead to serious sleep problems.
- Avoidance of Accident-Related Triggers: Victims may avoid specific roads, refuse to discuss the crash, or distance themselves from anything that reminds them of the trauma.
- Hypervigilance and Exaggerated Startle Response: People with accident-related PTSD are often constantly on edge, easily startled, or unusually sensitive to loud noises and sudden movements.
- Depression, Emotional Numbness, or Withdrawal: Many victims lose interest in daily life, withdraw from others, and struggle with responsibilities, often resulting in isolation and work-related challenges.
Studies show that PTSD symptoms often emerge within the first year after a crash. Nearly a third of survivors still experience PTSD at six months, over a quarter continue to struggle at twelve months, and another 8% develop symptoms for the first time at the one-year mark.
These numbers show how long-lasting and sometimes chronic, accident-related PTSD can be. That’s why emotional trauma must be taken just as seriously as physical injuries.
Proving PTSD: The Evidence Challenge
New York does allow accident victims to seek compensation for psychological injuries, but the legal standards are strict. Because emotional trauma is not outwardly visible, courts require strong proof connecting the PTSD to the negligent party’s actions.
1. New York’s Zone of Danger Rule
New York follows the zone of danger doctrine for emotional distress claims. To recover compensation, a plaintiff generally must show one of these elements:
- They were in actual physical danger due to the defendant’s negligence.
- They witnessed a serious injury or death of an immediate family member during the accident.
Simply hearing about the accident or being emotionally affected afterward is not enough. The claimant must have been close enough to fear for their own safety or witness a loved one being harmed.
2. A Professional PTSD Diagnosis
Courts require a formal diagnosis from a qualified mental health professional, such as:
- Psychologists
- Psychiatrists
- Licensed clinical social workers
Therapist notes, clinical evaluations, treatment records, and the criteria published in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders by the American Psychiatric Association (APA) all serve as necessary legal evidence.
3. Proof of Causation
The plaintiff must also show that:
- The PTSD resulted from the accident.
- The defendant’s negligence was the direct cause.
Proving causation becomes more complex when the victim has a history of anxiety, depression, or trauma. Expert testimony is often essential to distinguish pre-existing conditions from the psychological harm caused specifically by the crash.
Overcoming Evidence Obstacles in PTSD Claims
Because insurers often question or minimize these invisible injuries, documenting PTSD is crucial. Strong evidence may include:
| Type of Evidence | Description | Why It Matters |
| Expert Testimony | Evaluations and statements from psychologists or psychiatrists. | Confirms PTSD diagnosis, connects symptoms to the accident, and explains functional limitations. |
| Treatment Records | Therapy notes, medication records, and clinical assessments. | Shows symptom severity, duration, treatment progress, and consistency of the diagnosis. |
| Personal Journals | Daily entries describing emotions, triggers, flashbacks, sleep issues, or panic attacks. | Demonstrates how the condition affects daily functioning and tracks symptom patterns over time. |
| Family, Friend, or Co-Worker Statements | Written observations from people who interact with the victim regularly. | Highlights noticeable personality changes, emotional withdrawal, behavioral shifts, or work issues after the accident. |
| Employment and Income Documentation | Pay stubs, HR statements, attendance records, or disability paperwork. | Establishes lost wages, reduced hours, or job instability caused by PTSD. |
Victims should begin documenting their symptoms early and continue to do so throughout their recovery. A skilled Syracuse car accident lawyer can help gather the proper evidence and challenge the insurer’s attempts to downplay emotional trauma.
Damages Available for PTSD in New York
Successful PTSD claims may allow compensation for:
- Therapy and counseling costs
- Psychiatric treatment and medication
- Lost wages or reduced earning ability
- Future mental-health treatment needs
- Pain and suffering
- Emotional distress and diminished quality of life
A qualified car accident attorney can help you understand the full extent of your PTSD-related losses. At Catalano Law, we fight for compensation that reflects your real needs, from ongoing treatment to lost income, so you can focus on rebuilding your life.
Work With an Experienced New York Personal Injury Attorney
Our Syracuse car accident lawyers understand how deeply PTSD can disrupt your life. As trusted advocates for victims throughout Central New York and the Southern Tier, we’ve helped thousands secure justice and win millions in settlements. We can protect your rights and help you pursue the compensation you need to heal.
Contact us today for a free, confidential consultation, and let us put our thirty years of experience to work for you.
