Request Free Consultation
To get answers to questions about your injury, contact Catalano Law for a FREE case evaluation. We’ll assess your case, explain your legal options, and recommend the next steps at no cost. We’re here when you need us.
Contact Form
General Contact Form
New York experiences thousands of car accidents annually, including more than 11,000 injury crashes in 2022 alone. Most occur on public roads where liability is straightforward, but accidents on private property, like parking lots, private roads, or driveways, can be more complicated to resolve.
Property owners may sometimes be held responsible for unsafe conditions or poor signage. However, a driver’s actions, such as speeding or ignoring traffic rules, can also play a role. If you’ve been injured in a crash, understanding how liability works is crucial to protecting your rights and pursuing the financial compensation you deserve.
Learn how liability applies to private property accidents in New York and how the experienced Syracuse car accident lawyers at Catalano Law can help you prove your losses and fight for the damages you’re entitled to.
Determining Fault in Private Property Accidents
Determining liability for crashes on private property involves several factors, including the property owner’s duty of care and the actions of the drivers involved. Since traffic laws are less strictly enforced on private property, fault is often assessed using the following principles:
Property Owner’s Duty of Care
Under New York’s premises liability laws, property owners must:
- Maintain a safe environment for drivers and pedestrians
- Address hazards like potholes, ice, or damaged pavement
- Provide proper signage, such as stop signs, yield signs, and directional arrows
If property owners fail to uphold these responsibilities and a collision occurs, they may be held responsible for accidents on their premises.
Driver Negligence
Drivers may also be held accountable when their actions contribute to a crash, such as:
- Failing to follow traffic rules, such as ignoring posted signs or not yielding the right of way
- Driving recklessly by speeding, tailgating, or making unsafe turns
- Engaging in distracted driving, like texting, eating, or using a GPS while behind the wheel
In these cases, the driver’s actions can result in them being fully or partially liable for the accident.
Contributory Negligence
New York’s comparative negligence rule divides fault among all parties involved in an accident and adjusts compensation based on each party’s level of responsibility. For example, if a property owner failed to repair a hazard like a pothole and you didn’t follow posted signs, both parties could share liability.
You can recover damages even if you were partially at fault, but only if you are 50% or less responsible for the accident. Your settlement will be reduced according to the percentage of fault you have. For instance, if you’re found to be 20% responsible, your final award would be reduced by that same percentage.
Common Scenarios Involving Private Property Accidents
Accidents on private property can happen in various settings, each presenting unique liability challenges. To better understand how the concept works in real-life situations, here are some common private property accident scenarios:
| Type of Collision | Accident Scenario | Possible Liability |
| Parking Lot Collisions | Two drivers backing out of spaces collide, a speeding driver strikes another vehicle, or poor signage leads to confusion at intersections. | Property owners may share fault for inadequate lighting or poor signage.Distracted or reckless drivers may also share fault. |
| Driveway Accidents | A guest hits a stationary car while leaving, or a delivery driver strikes a parked car due to poor lighting or hazards in the driveway. | Homeowners may be liable for hazards such as poor maintenance or inadequate lighting.Drivers’ actions, such as inattention or speeding, also contribute to liability. |
| Crashes on Private Roads or Estates | Accidents occur due to uncleared debris on a gated community road or a guest crashes at a private event with inadequate traffic control. | Property owners may be liable for failing to clear debris or provide adequate traffic control.Reckless or negligent driving could also impact fault. |
What To Do After a Crash on Private Property
If you’re involved in a crash on private property, taking the proper steps can protect your rights:
- Document the Scene: Take photos of the damage, road conditions, and any signs or hazards present. This can help show what caused the accident and determine who’s responsible.
- Report the Incident: If necessary, notify the property owner and local authorities. Get a copy of the report for your records.
- Exchange Information: Collect contact and insurance information from everyone involved, including the driver’s auto insurance and the property owner’s homeowners’ or property insurance details.
- Seek Medical Attention: Even minor injuries should be documented for future claims. Visit a doctor immediately and keep all medical records for possible legal claims.
- Consult Legal Counsel: Speak with an attorney as soon as possible. Working with a qualified car accident lawyer can help you understand your options and determine liability.
Why Legal Guidance Matters
Determining fault in private property accidents often requires careful investigation and legal experience. An experienced car accident lawyer from Catalano Law can:
- Investigate the accident thoroughly, including property conditions and driver behavior
- Gather evidence, such as surveillance footage and witness statements
- Calculate a fair settlement for fair compensation for medical expenses, property damage, and lost wages
- Negotiate with insurance companies on your behalf
Work With Catalano Law for Your Private Property Accident Case
If you’ve been injured in a crash on private property, you deserve compassionate legal support from someone who understands New York’s traffic laws and premises liability rules. At Catalano Law, our Syracuse car accident lawyers have handled both types of cases and know how to determine fault and hold the responsible party accountable for your losses.
Contact us today for a free consultation to discuss your case. Our attorneys can explain your legal options and advise you on the steps to take for your claim.
